Unfair Dismissal Liverpool: Your Complete Guide to Employment Rights and Claims

Key Takeaways

Legal Point	Essential Information
Time Limits	You’ve got just three months less one day from your dismissal date to lodge a claim with an employment tribunal. Miss this deadline and you’ll likely lose your right to claim, regardless of merit.
Qualifying Period	Most employees need two years’ continuous service to claim ordinary unfair dismissal, though automatically unfair dismissals (like whistleblowing) require no qualifying period at all.
Tribunal Success Rates	Recent statistics show claimants win approximately 15-20% of unfair dismissal cases that reach full hearing, but many more settle beforehand through ACAS early conciliation.
Compensation Limits	The basic award caps at £21,000 (as of 2024/25), whilst the compensatory award maxes out at £115,115 or 52 weeks’ gross pay—whichever’s lower.
Legal Costs	Employment tribunals don’t normally award costs to winning parties, meaning you won’t automatically recover solicitor fees even if you succeed completely.
ACAS Conciliation	You must notify ACAS before submitting an ET1 claim form. This mandatory early conciliation period can pause your three-month time limit, giving you crucial extra days.
Reinstatement Reality	Tribunals rarely order employers to take dismissed employees back. Most successful claimants receive financial compensation instead, as reinstatement proves impractical in the vast majority of cases.

Introduction: Understanding Your Rights When You’ve Been Dismissed

Getting sacked feels awful, doesn’t it? That sick feeling in your stomach, the worry about bills, the anger at being treated unfairly—I’ve seen it all in my years practising employment law in Liverpool. Most people who walk through our doors at Wolf Law genuinely don’t know whether they’ve been dismissed unfairly or whether their employer actually had the right to let them go.

Here’s the thing: unfair dismissal doesn’t mean your employer had absolutely no reason to dismiss you. Rather, it means they either dismissed you for an inadmissible reason, failed to follow proper procedures, or acted unreasonably in treating their reason as sufficient grounds for dismissal. This distinction trips up countless employees across Liverpool and the Wirral who assume they’ve no case simply because their employer pointed to something they’d done wrong.

Furthermore, the law surrounding unfair dismissal involves strict time limits, qualifying periods, and procedural requirements that catch out even experienced HR departments. Understanding your rights from the moment you receive notice—or in some cases, the moment you walk out—makes all the difference between a successful claim and a missed opportunity.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about unfair dismissal claims in Liverpool. You’ll learn what actually constitutes unfair dismissal under the Employment Rights Act 1996, how to recognise the warning signs before it happens, what steps you must take immediately after dismissal, and crucially, how to protect your legal position throughout. We’ll also examine the tribunal process, realistic compensation expectations, and when it’s worth instructing a solicitor to handle your case.

What Actually Counts as Unfair Dismissal Under UK Law

The Legal Framework: Employment Rights Act 1996

The Employment Rights Act 1996 sets out your fundamental rights when it comes to dismissal. Section 94 gives qualifying employees the right not to be unfairly dismissed, whilst sections 98-107 detail what makes a dismissal fair or unfair. In practice, your employer needs to show they dismissed you for one of the potentially fair reasons set out in section 98(2), then prove they acted reasonably in all the circumstances.

Those potentially fair reasons include capability or qualifications, conduct, redundancy, statutory restriction, or “some other substantial reason.” Mind you, just because your employer can point to one of these categories doesn’t automatically make your dismissal fair. They’ve still got to demonstrate they followed a fair procedure and that dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses available to a reasonable employer.

The burden of proof shifts during a tribunal claim. Your employer must first prove the reason for dismissal and that it potentially qualifies as fair. Only then does the tribunal consider whether they acted reasonably. This procedural point matters enormously because many Liverpool employers struggle to articulate a clear, consistent reason for dismissal when challenged.

Automatically Unfair Dismissals That Don’t Require Two Years’ Service

Certain dismissals are automatically unfair regardless of your length of service. These protected reasons include dismissal for pregnancy or maternity reasons, health and safety complaints, asserting statutory rights, whistleblowing, trade union membership or activities, and requesting flexible working. Consequently, even if you’ve worked somewhere for just three weeks, dismissal for these reasons gives you a valid tribunal claim.

I’ve handled numerous cases where Liverpool employers dismissed employees in their probation period, assuming they were protected from claims. They weren’t. Dismissing a probationer for raising a health and safety concern about faulty equipment remains automatically unfair, regardless of service length. The employer’s shocked face when they receive the ET1 claim form never gets old.

The whistleblowing provisions under the Employment Rights Act 1996 (sections 103A and 47B) offer particularly strong protection. You’re protected if you make a qualifying disclosure about criminal offences, health and safety dangers, environmental damage, miscarriages of justice, or deliberate concealment of any of these. However, you must reasonably believe your disclosure is in the public interest and made in good faith.

• Pregnancy and maternity dismissals: Protected from the moment you notify your employer until the end of maternity leave
• Health and safety dismissals: Covers refusing dangerous work or raising legitimate safety concerns with your employer or HSE
• Whistleblowing dismissals: Requires a qualifying disclosure made in accordance with the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998
• Trade union dismissals: Protects union membership, activities, and the right to be accompanied at disciplinary hearings
• Asserting statutory rights: Includes claiming minimum wage, holiday pay, rest breaks, or other statutory entitlements

These automatically unfair reasons come up frequently in employment law claims across Liverpool, particularly in sectors like hospitality, retail, and construction where employees may lack knowledge of their protections.

The Two-Year Qualifying Period and What It Really Means

For ordinary unfair dismissal claims, you generally need two years’ continuous service with your employer. This qualifying period starts from your first day of work and runs until your effective date of termination. Breaks in service can reset the clock unless you’re covered by specific continuity provisions in the Employment Rights Act 1996.

Continuous service isn’t always straightforward, though. If you were laid off, on strike, or temporarily seconded, these periods might still count towards your two years. Similarly, TUPE transfers preserve your continuity, meaning your previous employer’s service counts when calculating whether you meet the threshold.

The effective date of termination usually means your last working day or the expiry of your notice period. However, if your employer dismissed you without notice when they should have given it, the statutory minimum notice period gets added to your dismissal date. This addition can sometimes push an employee just over the two-year mark, creating a valid claim where none initially appeared possible.

Recognising the Warning Signs Before Dismissal Happens

Changes in Treatment and Documentation Patterns

Employers rarely dismiss someone out of the blue. Typically, you’ll notice shifts in how you’re treated weeks or months beforehand. Suddenly, your manager starts documenting every minor issue. You’re excluded from meetings you’d normally attend. Your workload changes inexplicably. These patterns often signal an employer building a case for dismissal.

In Liverpool firms, I’ve seen managers suddenly become hyper-critical after an employee raises a grievance or takes maternity leave. They’ll start scrutinising timekeeping that was previously ignored, or questioning work quality that’s been acceptable for years. This documented “evidence” then forms the basis for capability or conduct allegations.

You should keep your own contemporaneous notes when these patterns emerge. Record dates, times, witnesses, and exactly what was said or done. These notes become invaluable evidence if you later need to demonstrate less favourable treatment or that your employer manufactured allegations. Moreover, they help you recall specific details months later when you’re preparing witness statements for tribunal.

Suspension and Investigation Procedures

Suspension often precedes dismissal, particularly in misconduct cases. Your employer should make clear that suspension is a neutral act, not a disciplinary sanction, and it should be on full pay. However, many Liverpool employers use suspension punitively, leaving employees hanging for weeks without communication whilst they decide what to do.

If you’re suspended, you’re entitled to know why. Vague allegations of “inappropriate behaviour” or “concerns about your conduct” aren’t sufficient. You need enough detail to prepare your response, though your employer needn’t reveal every piece of evidence at the suspension stage. They should also indicate roughly how long the investigation will take, though extensions do happen.

During suspension, your employer should maintain reasonable contact and keep you informed of progress. Radio silence for months can amount to a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence, potentially giving you grounds for constructive dismissal if you choose to resign. Additionally, unreasonably lengthy suspensions can prejudice any later disciplinary process, potentially rendering a subsequent dismissal unfair.

The Grievance You Raised That Suddenly Made You Unpopular

Raising a grievance shouldn’t make your position vulnerable, but it sometimes does. If you complain about discrimination, harassment, or statutory breaches, then suddenly face disciplinary action, the timing raises obvious questions. Employment tribunals examine these situations closely, looking for evidence of victimisation or retaliatory dismissal.

I represented a Liverpool care worker who raised concerns about inadequate PPE during the pandemic. Within a fortnight, her employer commenced capability proceedings alleging poor performance—despite years of satisfactory appraisals. The tribunal didn’t believe the employer’s explanation. The timing was too convenient, and the employer couldn’t produce credible evidence of performance issues predating the grievance.

If you’re in this position, make sure someone else knows what’s happening. Contact Wolf Law’s employment team before responding to any disciplinary allegations. We can review whether your situation suggests victimisation and advise on protecting your position throughout the process. Sometimes, sending the right letter at the right moment prevents an employer from proceeding with an unjustified dismissal.

The Dismissal Process: What Your Employer Must Do

Fair Investigation Requirements Before Any Disciplinary

Before disciplining or dismissing you, your employer must conduct a reasonable investigation. What counts as “reasonable” depends on the circumstances, but generally includes interviewing relevant witnesses, gathering documentary evidence, and giving you opportunity to respond to allegations. The landmark case of British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell [1980] ICR 303 established that employers must hold a genuine belief in guilt, based on reasonable grounds following reasonable investigation.

Many Liverpool employers skip proper investigation, particularly in smaller firms without dedicated HR support. They might dismiss based on customer complaints without interviewing you, or they’ll accept one person’s account without checking if anyone else witnessed the alleged incident. These procedural failures often make an otherwise potentially fair dismissal unfair.

The investigation should be conducted by someone independent of the disciplinary process where possible. So, the person investigating misconduct allegations shouldn’t also decide your fate at the disciplinary hearing. Whilst not always practical in small firms, tribunals expect employers to minimise conflicts of interest and maintain procedural fairness throughout.

• Investigation should be proportionate to the seriousness of allegations
• You’re entitled to know what you’re accused of and who’s making accusations
• Investigators must consider evidence that might exonerate you, not just evidence supporting allegations
• Investigation findings should be documented in a report available to the disciplinary hearing chair
• The investigator shouldn’t predetermine the outcome or recommend dismissal

Your Rights During Disciplinary Hearings

You’ve got the statutory right to be accompanied at a disciplinary hearing by a trade union representative or a work colleague. Your companion can address the hearing, sum up your case, and confer with you, but they can’t answer questions on your behalf. Your employer must let you know about this right when they invite you to the hearing.

The hearing invitation should give you adequate notice—usually at least 48 hours, though more time is appropriate for complex cases. The invitation must explain the allegations clearly enough for you to prepare your response. Receiving a vague allegation of “gross misconduct” the day before a hearing doesn’t give you fair opportunity to defend yourself.

At the hearing itself, your employer should present their evidence and give you full opportunity to respond. You can call relevant witnesses, present documents, and question the evidence against you. The hearing chair should keep an open mind until hearing all the evidence. If they’ve already decided to dismiss you before the hearing even starts, that’s procedurally unfair.

After hearing all the evidence, the chair should adjourn to consider their decision. They shouldn’t dismiss you on the spot during the hearing. You’re entitled to receive the decision in writing, along with clear reasons for dismissal and information about your right to appeal. This written decision becomes crucial evidence if you later bring a tribunal claim.

The Appeal Process and Why It Matters for Your Claim

You’ve got the right to appeal any dismissal decision. The appeal should ideally be heard by someone more senior than the original decision-maker, and it should be a genuine reconsideration of the decision, not just a rubber-stamping exercise. In Taylor v OCS Group Ltd [2006] ICR 1602, the Court of Appeal confirmed that a fair appeal can remedy defects in the original disciplinary process.

This principle matters enormously in practice. If your initial dismissal was procedurally flawed but your employer conducted a thorough appeal that addressed those defects, a tribunal might find the overall process fair. Conversely, a perfunctory appeal that merely pays lip service to the process won’t save an unfair dismissal.

Many Liverpool employees don’t bother appealing because they can’t see the point—they’ve already been sacked, after all. However, failing to appeal can harm your tribunal claim. Employers often argue you didn’t give them opportunity to put things right. Additionally, the appeal might reveal new evidence or admissions that strengthen your case.

Taking Your Unfair Dismissal Claim to Tribunal

The ACAS Early Conciliation Requirement

Before you can submit an ET1 claim form, you must notify ACAS of your potential claim. ACAS will contact your employer to see if they’ll engage in early conciliation to settle the dispute without tribunal proceedings. This process is mandatory, and you can’t bypass it even if you’re certain your employer won’t settle.

Early conciliation lasts up to six weeks, though it can be shorter if both parties decline conciliation or if one month passes without settlement. During this period, your three-month time limit is paused. When conciliation ends, ACAS issues you with an early conciliation certificate containing a reference number you’ll need for your ET1.

Importantly, the time extension only covers the conciliation period itself. If you delay notifying ACAS, you’re eating into your three-month window. I’ve seen Liverpool claimants miss tribunal deadlines because they assumed ACAS conciliation gave them unlimited extra time. It doesn’t. You must still act promptly, particularly as the three-month limit is strict and tribunals rarely extend it.

Completing the ET1 Claim Form Correctly

The ET1 claim form requires careful completion. You’ll need your ACAS early conciliation certificate number, details of your employment, and a clear explanation of your claim. Box 8.2, where you describe your claim, needs particular attention. You must explain what happened, when it happened, and why you believe you were unfairly dismissed.

Many claimants struggle with box 8.2, either providing insufficient detail or rambling for pages without clearly identifying the legal issues. You need to hit the sweet spot: enough detail for your employer and the tribunal to understand your case, but structured clearly enough to be comprehensible. Consider getting advice from employment law specialists before submitting, as errors or omissions can weaken your claim.

You’ll also need to specify the remedy you’re seeking. For unfair dismissal, you can claim reinstatement, re-engagement, or compensation. Most claimants seek compensation as reinstatement rarely works in practice. You must also indicate whether you’re claiming other things alongside unfair dismissal, such as discrimination, breach of contract, or unlawful deduction of wages.

Understanding Tribunal Procedure and What to Expect

Once your claim is accepted, the tribunal sends a copy to your employer, who must submit an ET3 response within 28 days. The ET3 sets out your employer’s defence, explaining why they believe they dismissed you fairly. Reading their response often reveals which arguments they’ll run at hearing.

The tribunal will then case-manage your claim, issuing orders for disclosure of documents, exchange of witness statements, and agreeing a bundle of relevant documents. These procedural steps happen before any final hearing. Preliminary hearings might address jurisdictional issues like whether you’ve got qualifying service or whether your claim was brought in time.

At the final hearing, both sides present evidence through witness statements, then witnesses are cross-examined. The tribunal—typically comprising an employment judge and two lay members—then decides whether you were unfairly dismissed. They’ll issue a written judgment, usually within a few weeks of the hearing, setting out their findings and any compensation awarded.

Most tribunals now operate with some degree of flexibility regarding remote hearings, though final hearings often take place in person. Liverpool employment tribunal hearings usually take place at the Liverpool Civil and Family Court, though some may be listed in Manchester depending on capacity.

Calculating and Maximising Your Compensation

The Basic Award Formula

If you win your unfair dismissal claim, you’ll receive a basic award calculated similarly to statutory redundancy pay. You get one and a half weeks’ pay for each complete year of service where you were aged 41 or over, one week’s pay for each year aged 22-40, and half a week’s pay for each year under 22. Your service is capped at 20 years, and weekly pay is capped at £700 (for dismissals from 6 April 2024).

So, if you’re 45 years old with 10 years’ service earning £35,000 annually (£673 per week), your basic award would be 10 × 1.5 × £673 = £10,095. However, if you earned £50,000 annually (£962 per week), you’d only get 10 × 1.5 × £700 = £10,500 because of the statutory cap.

The tribunal can reduce your basic award if you caused or contributed to your dismissal, or if you unreasonably refused an offer of reinstatement. Reductions for contributory conduct typically range from 10% to 100%, depending on the severity of your actions and how much they contributed to your dismissal. Therefore, even if your dismissal was unfair, your own misconduct might significantly reduce your compensation.

The Compensatory Award and Future Losses

The compensatory award aims to compensate you for actual financial losses caused by dismissal. This includes immediate loss of earnings from dismissal to tribunal hearing, future loss of earnings, loss of statutory rights (usually a nominal £500), and pension losses. You must prove your losses with evidence like payslips, job applications, and evidence of attempts to find work.

Future loss calculation depends on how long the tribunal thinks it’ll take you to find equivalent employment. In the current Liverpool job market, tribunals might assess future loss anywhere from a few weeks to 18 months or more, depending on your age, qualifications, and the availability of suitable jobs. Specialist or senior roles typically command longer future loss periods.

Your compensatory award is capped at £115,115 or 52 weeks’ gross pay, whichever is lower (for dismissals from 6 April 2024). Consequently, if you earned £100,000 annually, your cap would be £100,000 (52 weeks), not the higher statutory maximum. This cap catches many higher earners by surprise, as their actual losses often exceed the compensation they can recover.

• Keep detailed records of job applications and interviews to prove mitigation
• Don’t turn down suitable alternative employment without good reason
• Consider tax implications—the first £30,000 of compensation is usually tax-free
• Pension loss calculations can be complex and may require expert evidence
• Interest accrues on tribunal awards from the date of calculation to payment

You’re under a duty to mitigate your losses by seeking alternative employment. Sitting at home and making no effort to find work will reduce your compensatory award. Conversely, if you find new employment quickly, your losses reduce accordingly. The tribunal expects you to act reasonably to minimise your financial losses following dismissal.

Aggravated Damages and Injury to Feelings

Standard unfair dismissal claims don’t include injury to feelings awards—those are reserved for discrimination claims. However, in exceptional cases involving psychiatric injury caused by the manner of dismissal, you might recover damages for personal injury. You’d need medical evidence proving a recognised psychiatric condition resulted from your dismissal.

Aggravated damages can be awarded if your employer dismissed you in a particularly high-handed, malicious, or oppressive manner. These remain rare in straightforward unfair dismissal claims, though they appear more frequently where dismissal involves discrimination or whistleblowing. The threshold is high—merely feeling upset or angry about your dismissal won’t suffice.

If you’re pursuing a discrimination claim alongside unfair dismissal, injury to feelings awards follow the Vento bands established in Vento v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2003] ICR 318. These bands are inflation-adjusted annually and can add substantial sums to your overall compensation, particularly for serious discriminatory dismissals.

When You Should Instruct a Solicitor

DIY Versus Professional Representation

You can represent yourself at tribunal—many claimants do. However, employment law involves complex procedural rules, legal tests, and tactical decisions where experience matters. Your employer will likely instruct solicitors or specialist employment consultants, giving them significant advantages in presenting their case.

I’ve watched capable, intelligent people struggle at tribunal because they didn’t understand evidential rules or how to cross-examine witnesses effectively. They knew their own story but couldn’t translate that into compelling legal arguments. Meanwhile, their employer’s representative systematically dismantled their case using techniques honed over hundreds of hearings.

Professional representation becomes particularly valuable in complex cases involving discrimination, whistleblowing, or substantial compensation. If you’re likely to recover significant compensation, paying for a solicitor might cost you 20-30% of your award through legal fees, but it substantially increases your prospects of winning. Consequently, the net benefit often justifies the cost.

What Legal Fees Actually Cost

Employment solicitors typically charge hourly rates ranging from £200 to £400+ depending on location and experience. Liverpool rates tend toward the lower end compared to London, but you’re still looking at several thousand pounds for full tribunal representation. Some solicitors offer fixed fees for specific stages, like drafting your ET1 or preparing your witness statement.

Alternative funding options include legal expenses insurance (check your home insurance policy), trade union representation if you’re a member, or conditional fee arrangements where you only pay if you win. However, conditional fees in employment cases are less common than in personal injury work, as success rates are lower and outcomes more uncertain.

Be wary of claims management companies offering “no win, no fee” employment services. Some charge success fees of 25-35% of your compensation, potentially leaving you with less than you’d get after paying a solicitor’s standard fees. Always check what percentage they’ll take and whether you’re better off paying hourly rates instead.

Tribunals rarely award costs against unsuccessful claimants unless they’ve behaved unreasonably, vexatiously, or abusively. This no-costs culture means you can generally bring a genuine claim without risking having to pay your employer’s legal fees if you lose. However, if you’re dishonest or waste tribunal time with a hopeless claim, cost orders remain possible.

Frequently Asked Questions About Unfair Dismissal in Liverpool

Conclusion: Protecting Your Rights After Dismissal in Liverpool

Getting dismissed unfairly ranks among the most stressful experiences you’ll face. Beyond the immediate financial worry, there’s the emotional impact of feeling wronged and the uncertainty about what happens next. Throughout my years handling unfair dismissal claims across Liverpool and the Wirral, I’ve seen how proper legal support at the right time makes all the difference between a successful claim and a missed opportunity.

Remember that time limits in employment law are ruthlessly strict. That three-month deadline isn’t negotiable, and missing it usually means losing your claim regardless of merit. Therefore, if you believe you’ve been unfairly dismissed, don’t wait—contact ACAS to start early conciliation, gather your evidence, and seek legal advice about your prospects. Even if you ultimately decide not to pursue a tribunal claim, understanding your position and options gives you back some control over a difficult situation.

Unfair dismissal law exists to protect employees from arbitrary or unjust treatment whilst recognising that employers must be able to manage their workforce effectively. Finding the balance between these competing interests requires careful navigation of complex legal tests, procedural requirements, and tactical decisions. Whilst this guide provides a comprehensive overview, nothing replaces tailored advice on your specific circumstances from an experienced employment solicitor.

If you’re facing dismissal or have already been dismissed from your job in Liverpool, Wolf Law’s employment team can provide the specialist advice you need. We’ll review your situation honestly, explain your realistic prospects, and guide you through every stage of the process—from ACAS early conciliation through to final tribunal hearing if necessary. Don’t let strict time limits or procedural complexity cost you the compensation you deserve.

---

Legal Disclaimer

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific advice relating to your circumstances, please contact Wolf Law directly to arrange a consultation with one of our qualified solicitors.